Blog: Wisdom From Wizards

AI Can’t Solve Your Messaging Problem — Here’s What Can

Written by Nitin Kartik | Feb 11, 2025 4:41:45 PM

Why Messaging Matters More Than Ever

Tech founders, if your customers don’t immediately understand what you do, why it matters, or why they should choose you over competitors, you don’t have a marketing problem — you have a messaging problem.

In an era where AI tools like ChatGPT can generate polished marketing copy in seconds, standing out isn’t about having sleek messaging — it’s about having the right messaging. The biggest challenge today isn’t looking professional; it’s being clear, authentic, and compelling.

The Messaging Trap: Why Customers Are Confused

Many startups struggle with messaging because they focus on what they do instead of why it matters. If your prospects hesitate, ask too many clarifying questions, or mistake you for just another option in the market, your messaging isn’t doing its job.

Here are some key red flags that signal a messaging problem:

  • Your messaging feels too broad or generic. If your tagline could apply to multiple companies, it’s not differentiated enough.
  • Customers are comparing you to the wrong competitors. If you’re being bucketed with solutions that don’t truly compete with yours, your messaging isn’t positioning you correctly.
  • Deals are stalling because prospects don’t grasp the urgency of your solution. Confused customers don’t buy — clear messaging drives action.

Authenticity: The New Competitive Advantage

In my latest Wisdom from Wizards episode featuring Shah Choudhury at Salesforce, we discussed the power of authentic messaging. Shah made an important observation: sleek, overproduced marketing is no longer enough. Customers have grown skeptical because it’s too easy to fake. AI-generated marketing copy can look polished, but what customers crave is real, meaningful connections with brands that truly understand their pain points.

The brands that win in today’s noisy landscape are those that make their value unmistakably clear.

How to Fix Your Messaging

If you’re dealing with customer confusion, here are three key steps to refine your messaging:

  1. Clarify Your Value Proposition — Can you describe what you do in one sentence without using jargon? Your value proposition should be simple, clear, and compelling.
  2. Differentiate Clearly — Why should customers choose you over the competition? Your messaging should highlight what makes you uniquely valuable.
  3. Test and Iterate — Run your messaging by potential customers, sales teams, and investors. If they don’t immediately get it, neither will your market.

Don’t Let Confusion Cost You Customers

If your messaging isn’t clear, your prospects won’t stick around to figure it out. Your job isn’t just to explain what you do — it’s to make your value impossible to ignore.

For more insights on crafting messaging that converts, check out my Amazon Bestseller, Product Marketing Wisdom.

Amazon Bestseller: Product Marketing Wisdom by Nitin Kartik